There’s no doubt AI is seeping deeper into our daily lives, but has it replaced decision-making itself? That question was explored on a recent episode of Knowledge at Wharton’s Ripple Effect podcast, as Gideon Nave, associate professor of marketing and Carlos and Rosa de la Cruz Associate Professor, and postdoctoral researcher Steven Shaw shared insights from the experiments in their paper “Thinking — Fast, Slow, and Artificial: How AI is Reshaping Human Reasoning and the Rise of Cognitive Surrender” with host Dan Loney. The study builds on psychologist Daniel Kahneman’s two systems of thinking — either quick and intuitive or slow and deliberate — and suggests that a new, third system is emerging from human interactions with AI. This interview has been edited and condensed.
Dan Loney: What was the genesis of wanting to do this specific type of research?
Steven Shaw: Just observing how integrated AI has become in our daily lives, we felt that the ability to actually outsource thinking hadn’t really been studied. It’s sort of a profound idea.
Gideon Nave: I’ve been studying decision processes for a while, and we know that certain theories account for how people make decisions and how they use all the types of decision processes, from intuition to more deliberate, analytical thinking. And I think that technology in the past was integrated so you could offload some of your cognition to perform certain tasks, like using a calculator or using GPS to navigate. But to me, it sounds like the current theories of how humans make judgments and decisions must be going through some update once we have these devices that really, as Steve said, can replace thinking itself. It’s very important to start trying to account for this theoretically and define all sorts of tendencies and constructs, so we can really study it in the future.
SS: We have these classic models — for example, the dual-process model that Gideon has talked about: intuitions and deliberations. But the reliance that we see and the ability and the integration of AI that we see in society now really change the options that we have for making decisions. We need to update many of our old models in cognitive science and psychology and marketing.
DL: Gideon, it’s no longer a dual process. It’s a three-tiered process that we probably have to bring into play here, correct?
GN: Yeah. We added artificial cognition as a third module. I think what’s interesting is not only that we have this system and it adds to it, but the existence of this system — just its mere existence — changes how we engage our other thinking models. It changes how we use intuition; it changes how we use deliberation. And it also, surprisingly, changes how confident we are in our responses, even ones that are not really critically examined by ourselves.
DL: Adding this third component, does the dual process run into any roadblocks along the way as AI is becoming a greater component of our lives?
SS: Sure, and that’s one of the big things we show experimentally in the paper. We call it “cognitive surrender.” Basically, by just simply having the option of AI available for decision-making, people can surrender their thoughts to AI and let it think for them. They’re basically subverting the whole internal brain set of processes — substituting systems one and two and instead adopting answers from what we call system three. And as Gideon said, we saw that even when cognitive surrender is engaged, people adopt those answers and are more confident in those answers.
DL: Do they rely on those answers more often, then?
SS: In our experiments, it was optional. We just put ChatGPT in a window, and [about 1,300 participants performed] logic and reasoning questions. We said, “You can use AI if you want to, but you don’t have to.” We saw that over 50 percent of the time, they consulted ChatGPT. And once they consulted ChatGPT, adoption rates were very high. Even when AI gave them the incorrect answer, which we experimentally manipulated, people adopted the answer more than 80 percent of the time.
DL: This research also can lead us down the path to better understand what the relationship is going to be like with companies and their employees, and what’s going to be expected as we move forward.
GN: Let’s say it this way: If we are completely surrendering our thinking to AI, what value do we bring to a company? It’s not clear. So even this tendency to surrender may be something that in the future, companies would want to consider before they’re hiring somebody. I don’t want to have some person that basically is just giving me what the AI can already give me. I can get that by myself. It also tells us that if we think of the education of the next business leaders, obviously this is a skill that we want to make sure that people have and don’t lose. The capacity to think critically, to be able to check what the AI is giving you, has become more and more important over time.
DL: What did you take away from doing this research that resonated with you? Maybe something that you didn’t expect?
SS: How readily people were willing to cognitively surrender. That was pretty shocking. And how well the experiments worked, based on our theoretical contribution of this tri-system theory of cognition.
GN: You know, I’m just worried about the future. I think we all focus on this point where this singularity is going to happen, when AI will really outsmart us. And everybody thinks that this point will come from AI getting better and better. But there is an alternative story here of humans becoming more and more reliant on AI. Just like we now have an air conditioner that can set our temperature easily and we can move from one place to another without using any physical activity. Just like many of us have lost something because of this cultural or technological evolution, we may lose as a species something very critical to our existence, which is our capacity to think.
DL: Steve, having done this research, is there a next logical step that you would like to take?
SS: We now know that this phenomenon exists. AI gives us access to super-intelligence. There are a lot of instances when turning off thought can be a good thing. But in a lot of high-stakes contexts — education, health care — we don’t want that to be happening. How do we fight the rise of cognitive surrender in those contexts? Is it on the user side, on the human side, through AI literacy and training? Or is it on the UX design side, by putting in different types of prompting or roadblocks that try to induce critical thinking as those decisions are being made?
DL: That brings up the regulatory side of this — just how much of a role regulation may have in a lot of these developments.
GN: We’re going to see how the software companies, the AI companies, will respond to this, how policymakers will respond to this, how educational institutions will respond to this. I think what we have that is quite nice in this paper is a very clear method of measuring cognitive surrender. Now, we can try to take into the lab all sorts of interventions and see how we can maybe move it around, and that’s going to be quite a useful research tool.
Published as “Is AI Hijacking Our Brains?” in the Fall/Winter 2026 issue of Wharton Magazine.

